| Player | Year(s) | School |
|---|---|---|
| Beagle, Katie* | 2024 | University of Illinois at Springfield |
| Chantos, Ashlee* | 2024 | Winona State University |
| Demorest, Payton* | 2024 | Fox Valley Technical College |
| Frechette, Grace* | 2024 | St. Cloud State University |
| Graul, Teagan* | 2024 | Paris Junior College |
| Janik, Calli* | 2024 | Mount Mercy University |
| Kiesau, Kelsey* | 2024 | University of Wisconsin -La Crosse |
| Langrehr, Aliyah* | 2024 | University of Wisconsin -La Crosse |
| Makarewicz, Avary* | 2024 | University of Tennessee at Martin |
| Mori, Rachel* | 2024 | William Peace University |
| Osthoff, Valerie* | 2024 | Carroll University |
| Schott, Sydney* | 2024 | Spalding University |
| Schultz, Lindsey* | 2024 | Grinnell College |
| Watson, Alexis* | 2024 | Viterbo University |
| Willis, Mackenzie* | 2024 | Belmont University |
| Wolfe, Ashley* | 2024 | University of Wisconsin – Eau Claire |
* = The first 16 Steam softball players in the Northwoods League
