2019
| Robin Yount Award | Daryl Meyers
Luke Sommerfeld |
Benedictine (KS)
Clemson |
|
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Jake Thompson | Kentucky |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Will Klein | Eastern Illinois |  |
| Most Valuable Player | Cole Barr | Indiana |  |
2018
| Robin Yount Award | DJ Lee | Richmond |  |
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Jack Dunn | Northwestern |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Kevin Tibor | Carthage |  |
| Most Valuable Player | Dallas Beaver | Central Florida |  |
2017
| Robin Yount Award | Jack Dunn | Northwestern |  |
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Matthew Mika | Central Florida |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Austin Havekost | Kent State |  |
| Most Valuable Player | Rylan Thomas | Central Florida |  |
2016
| Robin Yount Award | Joe Duncan
Owen Miller |
Eastern Illinois
Illinois State |
|
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Matt Reardon | Florida Gulf Coast |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Marshall Kasowski | West Texas A & M |  |
| Most Valuable Player | Marshall Kasowski | West Texas A & M | |
2015
| Robin Yount Award | Doug Kraeger | Richmond |  |
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Anthony Massicci | Canisius |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Lake Bachar | UW-Whitewater |  |
| Most Valuable Player | Lucas Raley | Lake Erie College |  |
2014
| Robin Yount Award | Ryan Krill | Michigan State |  |
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Jake Noll | Florida Gulf Coast |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Shaun Anderson
Jake Tuttle |
Florida
UW-Milwaukee |
|
| Most Valuable Player | Brett Siddall | Canisius |  |
2013
| Robin Yount Award | Sawyer Polen | Kent State |  |
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Andrew Stevenson | LSU |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Tyler Thicke | UW-Milwaukee |  |
| Most Valuable Player | Mike Hollenbeck | Illinois State |  |
2012
| Robin Yount Award | Charlie Markson | Notre Dame |  |
| Kapco Steel Slugger | Eric Aguilera | Illinois State |  |
| Pitcher of the Year | Joe Greenfield | Eastern Illinois |  |
| Most Valuable Player | Forrest Chadwick | Southern Maine |  |
