Since Northwoods League baseball arrived in Green Bay in 2007, over 100 former players have gone on to play professional baseball. Eleven of those players have reached the highest level of their profession and have played in the Major Leagues. A comprehensive list of all players who are currently playing and have previously played professionally, following their stay in Green Bay, are listed below.
| NAME | POS | YEAR IN GB | AQUIRED | PRO AFFLIATE | LEVEL | TEAM |
| Scott Schebler | OF | 2010 | Drafted, 26th Rd.-Los Angeles Dodgers | Atlanta | MLB | Atlanta Braves |
| Adam Cimber | RHP | 2011 | Drafted, 9th Rd.-San Diego Padres | Cleveland | MLB | Cleveland Indians |
| Phillip Ervin | RF | 2011 | Drafted, 1st Rd.-Cincinnati Reds | Seattle | MLB | Seattle Mariners |
| Mitch Haniger | OF | 2011 | Drafted, 1st Rd.-Milwaukee Brewers | Seattle | MLB | Seattle Mariners |
| Matt Beaty | INF | 2014 | Drafted, 12th Rd.-Los Angeles Dodgers | Los Angeles (NL) | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| Tyler Olson | LHP | 2012 | Drafted, 7th Rd.-Seattle Mariners | Chicago (NL) | MLB | Chicago Cubs |
| Hunter Owen | OF | 2016 | Drafted, 25th Rd.-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pittsburgh | MLB | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| Jamie Ritchie | C/1B | 2014 | Drafted, 13th Rd.-Houston Astros | Houston | AAA | Round Rock Express |
| Hunter Owen | IF | 2016 | Drafted, 25th Rd.-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pittsburgh | AAA | Indianapolis Indians |
| Mike Ellenbest | RHP | 2016 | Drafted, 24th Rd.-Toronto Blue Jays | Toronto | AA | New Hampshire Fisher Cats |
| Matt De La Rosa | C | 2015 | Drafted, 28th Rd.-Baltimore Orioles | Baltimore | A+ | Frederick Keys |
| Luke Lind | RHP | 2015-16 | Signed, Free Agent | Los Angeles (AL) | A+ | Inland Empire 66ers |
| Jared Tobey | RHP | 2017 | Drafted, 30th Rd.-Detroit Tigers | Detroit | A+ | Lakeland Flying Tigers |
| Ethan Evanko | LHP | 2017 | Signed, Free Agent | Philadelphia | A+ | Clearwater Threshers |
| Jesse Berardi | INF | 2016 | Drafted, 10th Rd. -Cleveland Indians | Cleveland | A | Lake County Captains |
| Jonah Davis | OF | 2016 | Drafted, 15th Rd.-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pittsburgh | A | Greensborough Grasshoppers |
| Zach Biermann | 1B | 2016 | Drafted, 23rd Rd.-Houston Astros | Houston | A | Quad Cities River Bandits |
| Connor Wollersheim | LHP | 2017 | Drafted, 8th Rd.-New York Mets | New York (NL) | A | Columbia Fireflies |
| Travis Kuhn | RHP | 2018 | Drafted, 19th Rd.-Seattle Mariners | Seattle | A | West Virginia Power |
| Troy Johnston | OF | 2017 | Drafted, 17th Rd.-Miami Marlins | Miami | A- | Batavia Muckdogs |
| Jonathan Pendergast | RHP | 2017 | Drafted, 28th Rd.-Baltimore Orioles | Baltimore | A- | Aberdeen IronBirds |
| Matthew Acosta | OF | 2018 | Drafted, 12th Rd.-San Diego Padres | San Diego | A- | Tri-City Dust Devils |
| Preston Pavlica | OF | 2018 | Drafted, 24th Rd.-Houston Astros | Houston | A- | Tri-City Valley Cats |
| Mikey Filia | OF | 2017 | Drafted, 31st Rd.-Kansas City Royals | Kansas City | Rookie | Burlington Royals |
| Zack Plunkett | C | 2017 | Drafted, 20th Rd.-Los Angeles Dodgers | Los Angeles (NL) | Rookie | AZL Dodgers |
| McKinley Moore | RHP | 2018 | Drafted, 14th Rd.-Chicago White Sox | Philadelphia | MLB | Phillies |
| Jacob Buchberger | INF | 2019 | Signed, Free Agent | St. Louis | TBD | TBD |
| Josh Martin | RHP | 2011 | Drafted, 10th Rd.-Cleveland Indians | IND | Sugar Land Skeeters | |
| Andrew Ely | 2B | 2013 | Drafted, 32nd Rd.-Chicago Cubs | IND | Sioux Falls Canaries | |
| Mitch Ghelfi | C | 2013 | Drafted, 28th Rd.-Milwaukee Brewers | IND | Saint Paul Saints | |
| Jack Strunc | INF | 2015 | Drafted, 25th Rd.-Miami Marlins | IND | Chicago Deep Dish | |
| Brad Hamilton | C/1B | 2016 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | East Side Diamond Hoppers | |
| B.J. Sabol | RHP | 2016 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Washington WildThings | |
| Alonzo Jones | OF | 2017 | Drafted, 25th Rd.-Oakland A’s | IND | Tully Monsters | |
| Hunter Robichaux | RHP | 2017 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Florence Freedom | |
| Riley Mihalik | IF | 2018 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | East Side Diamond Hoppers | |
| Colby Morris | RHP | 2018 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Chicago Deep Dish | |
| Ryan Gowens | RHP | 2018 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Gateway Grizzlies | |
| PLAYERS NO LONGER AFFILIATED | ||||||
| NAME | POS | YEAR IN GB | AQUIRED | PRO AFFLIATE | LEVEL | LAST TEAM PLAYED FOR (MLB listed if reached majors, otherwise highest level in last pro season) |
| Daniel Robertson | OF | 2007 | Drafted, 33rd Rd.-San Diego Padres | Cleveland | MLB | Cleveland Indians |
| Rocky Gale | C | 2008 | Drafted, 24th Rd.-San Diego Padres | Los Angeles (NL) | MLB | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| Josh Prince | INF | 2008 | Drafted, 3rd Rd.-Milwaukee Brewers | Milwaukee | MLB | Milwaukee Brewers |
| Jacob May | OF | 2011 | Drafted, 3rd Rd.-Chicago White Sox | Chicago (AL) | MLB | Chicago White Sox |
| Tim Shibuya | RHP | 2010 | Drafted, 23rd Rd.-Minnesota Twins | Los Angeles (NL) | AAA | Oklahoma City Dodgers |
| Zak Hermans | RHP | 2011 | Drafted, 30th Rd.-Chicago Cubs | Chicago (NL) | AAA | Iowa Cubs |
| Bud Jeter | RHP | 2012 | Drafted, 25th Rd.-Arizona Diamondbacks | Arizona Diamondbacks | AAA | Reno Aces |
| Nick Torres | OF | 2013 | Drafted, 4th Rd.-San Diego Padres | Texas | AAA | Round Rock Express |
| Brad Zapenas | INF | 2010 | Drafted, 42nd Rd.-Chicago Cubs | Chicago NL | AA | Tennessee Smokies |
| Paul Hoenecke | 1B | 2011 | Drafted, 24th Rd.-Los Angels Dodgers | LA Dodgers | AA | Tulsa Drillers |
| Justin Seager | 1B | 2012 | Drafted, 12th Rd.-Seattle Mariners | Seattle | AA | Arkansas Travelers |
| Kevin Krause | C/RF | 2012 | Drafted, 9th Rd.-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pittsburgh | AA | Altoona Curve |
| Chris Hoo | C | 2012 | Drafted, 27th Rd.-Miami Marlins | Miami | AA | Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp |
| Brian Pearl | RHP | 2008 | Drafted, 9th Rd.-Cincinnati Reds | Cincinnati | A+ | Bakersfield Blaze |
| Owen Jones | RHP | 2010 | Drafted, 19th Rd.-Los Angeles Dodgers | Los Angeles (NL) | A+ | Rancho Cucamonga |
| Alec Mehrten | SS | 2011 | Drafted, 25th Rd.-Colorado Rockies | Colorado | A+ | Modesto Nuts |
| Lloyd “DJ” Slaton | RHP | 2012 | Drafted, 37th Rd.-Tampa Bay Rays | Tampa Bay | A+ | Charlotte Stone Crabs |
| Tripp Martin | 3B | 2013 | Drafted, 22nd Rd.-Texas Rangers | Texas | A+ | High Desert Mavericks |
| David Armendariz | OF | 2013 | Drafted, 23rd Rd.-Cleveland Indians | Cleveland | A+ | Lynchburg Hillcats |
| Matt Esparza | RHP | 2013 | Drafted, 14th Rd.-Cleveland Indians | Cleveland | A+ | Lynchburg Hillcats |
| Brian Trieglaff | RHP | 2013 | Drafted, 13th Rd.-New York Yankees | New York (AL) | A+ | Tampa Tarpons |
| Mikey Duarte | INF | 2015 | Drafted, 23rd Rd.-Chicago White Sox | Chicago (AL) | A+ | Winston-Salem Dash |
| Matt Gunter | LHP | 2016 | Drafted, 33rd Rd.-Toronto Blue Jays | Toronto | A+ | Dunedin Blue Jays |
| Nick O’Shea | C/1B | 2008 | Drafted, 24th Rd.-Cincinnati Reds | Cincinnati | A | Dayton Dragons |
| Matthew Argyropoulos | 1B/3B | 2009 | Drafted, 27th Rd.-Colorado Rockies | Colorado | A | Asheville Tourists |
| Dixon Anderson | RHP | 2009 | Drafted, 9th Rd.-Washington Nationals | Washington | A | Hagerstown Suns |
| Austin Blaski | LHP | 2011 | Drafted, 21st Rd.-Milwaukee Brewers | Milwaukee | A | Wisconsin Timber Rattlers |
| Jonathan Walsh | LF | 2011 | Drafted, 11th Rd.-Los Angeles Angels | LA Angels | A | Burlington Bees |
| Tyler Filliben | SS | 2011 | Drafted, 12th Rd.-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pittsburgh | A | West Virginia Power |
| Bradley Wallace | RHP | 2012 | Drafted, 10th Rd.-Tampa Bay Rays | Tampa Bay | A | Bowling Green Hot Rods |
| Federico Castagnini | SS | 2013 | Drafted, 30th Rd.-Baltimore Orioles | Baltimore | A | Delmarva Shorebirds |
| Ryan Howell | 2B | 2014 | Drafted, 15th Rd.-Oakland Athletics | Oakland | A | Beloit Snappers |
| Garrett Harrison | LHP | 2015 | Signed, Free Agent | Los Angeles (NL) | A | Great Lakes Loons |
| Kurt Yacko | RHP | 2007 | Drafted, 8th Rd.-Colorado Rockies | Pittsburgh | A- | Jamestown Jammers |
| Taylor Johnson | 2B | 2012 | Drafted, 40th Rd.-Detroit Tigers | Detroit | A- | Connecticut Tigers |
| J.D. Crowe | OF | 2013 | Drafted, 23rd Rd.-St. Louis Cardinals | St. Louis | A- | State College Spikes |
| Dean Long | 3B | 2014 | Drafted, 38th Rd.-Texas Rangers | Texas | A- | Spokane Indians |
| Duncan McAlpine | C | 2011-12 | Drafted, 16th Rd.-Detroit Tigers | Detroit | Rookie | GCL Tigers |
| Christian Cecilio | LHP | 2012 | Drafted, 22nd Rd.-San Diego Padres | San Diego | Rookie | AZL Padres |
| Ryan Matranga | C | 2013 | Drafted, 36th Rd.-San Francisco Giants | San Francisco | Rookie | AZL Giants |
| Ty Blankmeyer | 2B | 2015 | Drafted, 36th Rd.-Cincinnati Reds | Cincinnati | Rookie | Billings Mustangs |
| Logan Taylor | OF | 2015 | Drafted, 16th Rd.-Chicago White Sox | Cincinnati | Rookie | AZL Reds |
| Ricky Negron | INF | 2016 | Drafted, 34th Rd.-Atlanta Braves | Houston | Rookie | GCL Blue Jays |
| Adam Frost | INF | 2007 | Drafted, 21st Rd.-Detroit Tigers | IND | St. Paul Saints | |
| Ryan Cavan | INF | 2008 | Drafted, 16th Rd.-San Francisco Giants | IND | St. Paul Saints | |
| Kyle Robinson | OF/1B | 2009 | Drafted, 28th Rd.-Chicago White Sox | IND | Kansas City T-Bones | |
| Zach Varce | RHP | 2009 | Drafted, 11th Rd.-New York Yankees | IND | Lincoln Saltdogs | |
| Alex Schmarzo | RHP | 2010 | Drafted, 48th Rd.-Baltimore Orioles | IND | Edinburg Roadrunners | |
| Mike Thomas | LHP | 2010 | Drafted, 35th Rd.-Los Angeles Dodgers | IND | Somerset Patriots | |
| Tim Giel | RHP | 2011 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Washington Wild Things | |
| Joel Hutter | SS | 2009 | Drafted, 10th Rd.-Baltimore Orioles | IND | Schaumburg Boomers | |
| Elliot Waterman | LHP | 2012 | Drafted, 13th Rd.-Washington Nationals | IND | San Rafael Pacifics | |
| Taylor Black | RHP | 2012 | Drafted, 26th Rd.-Colorado Rockies | IND | Gary SouthShore Railcats | |
| Will Landsheft | RHP | 2012 | Drafted, 36th Rd.-Arizona Diamondbacks | IND | New Jersey Jackals | |
| Derek Callahan | LHP | 2013 | Drafted, 16th Rd.-New York Yankees | IND | Texas Air Hogs | |
| Ivan Vieitez | RHP | 2014 | Drafted, 27th Rd.-Los Angeles Dodgers | IND | Lake Erie Crushers | |
| Dane Hutcheon | 2B | 2015 | Drafted, 29th Rd.-Minnesota Twins | IND | Lake Erie Crushers | |
| Jeremy Graf | RHP | 2015 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Utica Unicorns | |
| Robb Paller | OF | 2015 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Birmingham-Bloomfield Beavers | |
| Danny Rosenbaum | INF | 2015 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | River City Rascals | |
| Jake Stolley | LHP | 2015 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Windy City ThunderBolts | |
| Sam Brunner | RHP | 2015 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Florence Freedom | |
| Quincy Nieporte | 1B | 2016 | Drafted, 26th Rd.-Philadelphia Phillies | IND | Schaumburg Boomers | |
| Brian Lees | C | 2016 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Gateway Grizzlies | |
| Ethan Westphal | RHP | 2016 | Signed, Free Agent | IND | Lake Erie Crushers |