| NAME | YEAR(S) WITH THE ROX | MLB ORGANIZATION | ROUND SELECTED |
| Angelo Altavilla | 2016-2017 | Arizona Diamondbacks | Free Agent (2019) |
| Josh Altmann | 2015 | Texas Rangers | 22nd (2015) |
| Austin Athmann | 2015 | Detroit Tigers | 14th (2016) |
| Drew Avans | 2017 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 33rd (2018) |
| Brandon Benson | 2015-2016 | St. Louis Cardinals | 20th (2017) |
| Brhet Bewley | 2016 | Kansas City Royals | 32nd (2018) |
| Austin Briggs | 2016 | Oakland Athletics | 29th (2018) |
| Michael Busch | 2017 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1st (2019) |
| Nick Bush | 2016 | Colorado Rockies | 8th (2018) |
| Trevor Charpie | 2015-2016 | Tampa Bay Rays | Free Agent (2017) |
| Will Craig | 2014 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 1st (2016) |
| Jack Cushing | 2017-2018 | Oakland Athletics | 22nd (2019) |
| Anthony Dimeglio | 2017 | Milwaukee Brewers | Free Agent (2019) |
| Finn Del Bonta-Smith | 2018 | Colorado Rockies | 22nd (2019) |
| Ben Deluzio | 2016 | Arizona Diamondbacks | Free Agent (2016) |
| Cameron Eden | 2017 | Toronto Blue Jays | 6th (2019) |
| Jay Flaa | 2013 | Baltimore Orioles | 6th (2015) |
| TJ Friedl | 2016 | Cincinnati Reds | Free Agent (2016) |
| Pedro Garcia | 2019 | Cincinnati Reds | Free Agent (2019) |
| Marshall Gilbert | 2018 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 29th (2019) |
| Lucas Gilbreath | 2015 | Colorado Rockies | 7th (2017) |
| Brian Glowicki | 2015-2016 | Chicago Cubs | 10th (2017) |
| Chad Hockin | 2014 | Chicago Cubs | 6th (2016) |
| Jason Hoppe | 2013 | Texas Rangers | 27th (2014) |
| Vincent Jackson | 2013 | St. Louis Cardinals | 14th (2016) |
| Evan Johnson | 2018 | Seattle Mariners | Free Agent (2019) |
| Denis Karas | 2016 | Miami Marlins | 10th (2017) |
| Brent Killam | 2017 | Los Angeles Angels | 11th (2019) |
| Mitchell Kranson | 2014 | Minnesota Twins | 9th (2016) |
| Shelby Lackey | 2016-2017 | Colorado Rockies | 17th (2018) |
| Carlos Lopez | 2012 | Miami Marlins | 10th (2013) |
| Lucas Long | 2012-2013 | Baltimore Orioles | 24th (2014) |
| John Matthews | 2017-2018 | Texas Rangers | 8th (2019) |
| Alex McRae | 2013 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 10th (2014) |
| Dan Metzdorf | 2016 | Chicago White Sox | 5th (2019) |
| Ben Meyer | 2012 | Miami Marlins | 29th (2015) |
| Andrew Mitchel | 2018 | San Diego Padres | 8th (2019) |
| Nick Morreale | 2017 | San Francisco Giants | 14th (2019) |
| Spencer Mraz | 2018 | Texas Rangers | 33rd (2019) |
| Chris Paul | 2012-2014 | Minnesota Twins | 6th (2015) |
| Zach Pop | 2015 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 7th (2017) |
| Brett Pope | 2015-2016 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 22nd (2017) |
| Trevor Putzig | 2017 | Baltimore Orioles | 17th (2018) |
| Luke Ringhofer | 2016-2017 | Baltimore Orioles | 22nd (2017) |
| Jackson Rose | 2017 | Miami Marlins | 35th (2018) |
| Dalton Sawyer | 2013-2014 | Oakland Athletics | 9th (2016) |
| Logan Salow | 2016 | Oakland Athletics | 6th (2017) |
| Ricardo Sanchez | 2017-2018 | Kansas City Royals | Free Agent (2019) |
| John Sansone | 2015 | Cincinnati Reds | 8th (2016) |
| Daniel Schneemann | 2017 | Cleveland Indians | 33rd (2018) |
| Kade Scivicque | 2014 | Detroit Tigers | 4th (2015) |
| Quinten Sefcik | 2016 | Cincinnati Reds | 24th (2019) |
| Shane Selman | 2017 | Oakland Athletics | 21st (2019) |
| Matt Shannon | 2016 | Toronto Blue Jays | 12th (2017) |
| Ryan Shreve | 2017 | Minnesota Twins | 16th (2019) |
| Jared Solomon | 2017 | Cincinnati Reds | 11th (2017) |
| Jake Stevenson | 2016-2018 | Cincinnati Reds | 10th (2019) |
| Rayne Supple | 2016 | Colorado Rockies | 13th (2018) |
| Nick Tanielu | 2012 | Houston Astros | 14th (2014) |
| Josh Taylor | 2014 | Philadelphia Phillies | Free Agent (2014) |
| Harrison Wenson | 2014 | Los Angeles Angels | 24th (2017) |
